Best Ice Maker Metal Arm Replacements for Whirlpool and Kenmore
If your ice maker arm isn’t signaling properly when the ice bin fills, you may be dealing with a worn or bent shut-off arm. A sturdy metal-arm replacement can restore reliable ice production across several brands, including Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, KitchenAid, and more. This guide highlights five quality options, detailing compatibility, durability, and installation considerations to help you choose a long-lasting solution for your refrigerator’s ice maker.
Product Overview
- Deckaura 5038 Ice Maker Shut-Off Arm
- MTZUL W11342242 Ice Maker Shut-Off Arm
- XwaYexa 5038 Icemaker Arm
- Supplying Demand W10378254 Ice Maker Shut-Off Arm
- Nvguoes W11215550 Ice Maker Arm Extension
Deckaura 5038 Icemaker Shut-Off Arm

The Deckaura 5038 Icemaker Shut-Off Arm is designed to replace standard shut-off arms on a wide range of top-brand refrigerators. It is crafted from high-quality stainless steel to deliver strength and durability, minimizing the risk of bending or wear during regular ice-making cycles. This part fits well with Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Jenn-Air, Amana, Magic Chef, Admiral, Norge, Roper, Kenmore, and more, consolidating compatibility in a single replacement option. The stainless steel construction helps ensure long service life, reducing the chances of premature failure that could interrupt ice production. Installation notes emphasize verifying model compatibility before purchase and aligning the arm’s pivot with the ice bucket mechanism.
Key considerations:
- Material: Stainless steel for durability and corrosion resistance.
- Compatibility: Broad support for major brands, helping reduce the need for multiple replacements.
- Durability: Built to withstand frequent contact with ice and cold temperatures.
MTZUL W11342242 Ice Maker Shut-Off Arm

The W11342242 shut-off arm from MTZUL is designed to detect ice levels and stop ice production when the bin fills. It fits several major brands, including Kenmore, Maytag, KitchenAid, Admiral, Amana, and Whirlpool. The arm features a combination of durable plastic and metal components to balance strength with flexible operation. It’s listed as an OEM-compatible replacement that aligns with common part numbers such as 2209675, 2304354, and WP2304354. This model helps address issues where the ice maker fails to stop at the right level or produces too much ice, restoring smooth operation when the arm or its flaps become bent or worn.
Key considerations:
- Materials: Durable mix of plastic and metal for reliable function.
- Compatibility: OEM-aligned with many popular ice maker lineups.
- Function: Restores proper shut-off timing to prevent overflow and jammed bins.
XwaYexa 5038 Icemaker Arm (2-Pack)

The XwaYexa 5038 Icemaker Arm is a two-pack replacement designed for Whirlpool and Kenmore refrigerators, compatible with WP67004028 and AP6010392 among other OEM numbers. Built from high-quality stainless steel, these arms offer durability and resilience against repeated ice contact and cold exposure. The kit emphasizes a universal fit across multiple brands, making it a practical choice for households with several refrigerator models. The 2-pack provides immediate redundancy, which can be beneficial for families that rely heavily on a steady ice supply or for technicians stocking their inventory.
Key considerations:
- Durability: Stainless steel construction for long life under cold conditions.
- Versatility: Broad compatibility with Whirlpool, Kenmore, and related models.
- Package: Includes two replacement arms for quick substitution.
Cawla Ice Maker Arm Replacement (WP67004028)

The Cawla ice maker arm is marketed as a direct replacement for Maytag, Kenmore, Whirlpool, and Whirl-Pool refrigerators bearing WP67004028 and AP4077996 numbers. It emphasizes sturdy construction with durable materials to ensure longevity and reliable shut-off behavior. The product listing highlights compatibility with a wide range of part numbers, making it a flexible option for those with multiple older or newer models. Users should confirm exact model compatibility before purchasing to ensure optimal fit and function. The replacement aims to prevent under- or over-ice production caused by a bent or worn shut-off arm.
Key considerations:
- Compatibility: Extensive part-number mapping reduces guesswork during replacement.
- Construction: Focus on durability to withstand ice-cold operation.
- Installation: Generally straightforward, but model verification is recommended.
Supplying Demand W10378254 Ice Maker Arm Replacement

The Supplying Demand W10378254 refers to a commonly used ice maker shut-off arm replacement, with related part numbers including WPW10378254 and AP6020635. The arm is designed to rise and trigger the shut-off mechanism as the ice bin fills. The description mentions a typical size of approximately 3 x 9-3/8 inches and notes the arm works with model-specific refrigerators. It also cautions on safe service practices, such as disconnecting power and water before maintenance. This part addresses common issues like too much ice or no ice by restoring proper shut-off action when worn or bent.
Key considerations:
- Sizing: Approximate dimensions to ensure a proper fit with your ice bin assembly.
- Function: Restores automatic shut-off to prevent overfilling.
- Safety: Emphasizes proper appliance disconnection during replacement.
ULAPITHI W11342242 Replacement Arm Fit

The ULAPITHI W11342242 ice maker shut-off arm is described as a durable option combining plastic and metal for consistent performance. It is positioned as compatible with a broad array of brands, including Kenmore, Maytag, KitchenAid, Amana, Whirlpool and beyond. The listing emphasizes accurate shut-off control to prevent overflow and ensure the ice-making cycle proceeds smoothly. The replacement part is aligned with common model numbers such as 2160689 and 2304354 to help users confirm compatibility before purchase.
Key considerations:
- Materials: Mixed plastic/metal construction for durability and precise operation.
- Compatibility: Broad coverage across major brands.
- Performance: Aims to maintain consistent ice production without overflow.
Buying Guide: Key Purchase Considerations
Choosing the right ice maker shut-off arm involves evaluating fit, durability, and ease of installation. Consider the following perspectives to ensure you select a replacement that provides reliable, long-term performance.
-
<liCompatibility and part numbers: Compare your refrigerator’s model number with the part numbers listed by the product. Some arms replace many different OEM numbers; verify that your unit is covered to avoid mismatches.
- Material quality: Stainless steel arms generally offer superior durability and resistance to corrosion in cold, damp environments. If a listing mentions metal or stainless steel, weigh that against any plastic components for longevity.
- Installation effort: Some parts are straightforward drop-in replacements; others may require minor disassembly. Check the included installation notes and ensure you have basic tools ready.
- Maintenance and replacement timing: Even durable arms can wear over time. If your ice maker frequently stops at the wrong level or overfills, a replacement may be warranted to restore proper operation.
- Warranty and seller reliability: Consider buying from sellers that provide clear warranty terms or return options. Look for listings with detailed compatibility notes and customer support.
Additional considerations include assessing whether you want a single replacement arm or a multi-pack. A multi-pack can be cost-effective for households with multiple units or for technicians stocking parts. Always verify the exact part number and model compatibility before purchasing to avoid returns and ensure a proper fit.